Neighbor charged with open murder after Walled Lake man killed - FOX 10 News | myfoxphoenix.com

Neighbor charged with open murder after Walled Lake man killed in dog dispute

Posted: Updated:
Charles Simkins in court Thursday Charles Simkins in court Thursday
Victim Edwin Criswell Victim Edwin Criswell
  • Neighbor charged with open murder after Walled Lake man killed in dog disputeMore>>

  • Walled Lake man killed in dispute over dog

    Walled Lake man killed in dispute over dog

    Wednesday, December 18 2013 8:17 AM EST2013-12-18 13:17:15 GMT
    Authorities say a dispute between neighbors in Walled Lake over a loose dog led to one man to fatally shoot another.
    Authorities say a dispute between neighbors in Walled Lake over a loose dog led to one man to fatally shoot another.
(WJBK) -

The man accused of pulling the trigger and killing his Walled Lake neighbor after a dispute over his dog was charged with open murder and felony firearm Thursday. The judge also issued no bond.

Police say 28-year-old Charles Simkins shot his 45-year-old neighbor, Edwin Criswell, late Tuesday night outside their homes in the 1100 block of Sigma St. in Walled Lake. Police say the victim confronted the suspect about his dog getting loose and into the victim's yard.

"He did admit to me that a fight ensued which he had punched the victim, knocking him down. He did admit to me that he had pulled his handgun out and fired rounds," Detective Anthony Noble from Walled Lake Police said Thursday in court.

Those shots hitting Criswell in the thigh caused him to bleed to death in his front yard. Police say the shooting is a result of a fight that began after Simkins' dog was the loose again.

"He stated that he found his dog in that area and he walked up to that residence with a loaded handgun," Noble says.

Simkins told police he needed his gun for protection when confronting Criswell, and had a license to carry although the license recently expired.

"It's not illegal to have guns. And if you have a CPL you have the right to carry," says defense attorney Todd Flodd.

As more details emerged in court Thursday Simkins took a moment to tell his family he misses them. But the wide-eyed, sighing Simkins was seemingly unsympathetic to the family and girlfriend of Criswell.  

"I think he did want to speak and he does want to stand up for his rights," Flodd believes.

Despite discussions of Simkins having no criminal past, that license to carry and the possibility of the former marine suffering from post traumatic stress disorder also was discussed.

"I mean think about it, I haven't been in battle but I want to visualize that for a second. It's pretty crazy, so it's something I'm going explore," Flodd says.

Now, two families fight back tears.

"It was expected. This is an open murder charge. So, it's unfortunate, but at the end of the day we're going to try this case in a courtroom. He's ready for that battle," says Flodd.

Charles Simkins is due back in court for his preliminary exam on Monday. If convicted, he faces life in prison.

  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Testimony: Renisha McBride pounded on homeowner's door before being fatally shot

    Testimony: Renisha McBride pounded on homeowner's door before being fatally shot

    Thursday, July 31 2014 7:47 PM EDT2014-07-31 23:47:47 GMT
    DETROIT (AP) -- A former medical examiner sparred with a prosecutor Thursday over a wound on the hand of a woman who was fatally shot on a Detroit-area porch, telling jurors it seems to fit the defense's claim that Renisha McBride was pounding on the homeowner's doors before she was killed.Dr. Werner Spitz, a forensic pathologist, said photos of McBride's body show a "small superficial laceration" on her left hand. It "could have come from pounding on something," Spitz said.The testimony was ...
    DETROIT (AP) -- A former medical examiner sparred with a prosecutor Thursday over a wound on the hand of a woman who was fatally shot on a Detroit-area porch, telling jurors it seems to fit the defense's claim that Renisha McBride was pounding on the homeowner's doors before she was killed.Dr. Werner Spitz, a forensic pathologist, said photos of McBride's body show a "small superficial laceration" on her left hand. It "could have come from pounding on something," Spitz said.The testimony was ...
  • Twitter tussle erupts after Price traded from Tampa Bay to Detroit

    Twitter tussle erupts after Price traded from Tampa Bay to Detroit

    Thursday, July 31 2014 7:31 PM EDT2014-07-31 23:31:19 GMT
    A friendly scuffle broke out on Twitter after the news Tampa Bay Rays pitcher David Price was traded to Detroit.
    A friendly scuffle broke out on Twitter after the news Tampa Bay Rays pitcher David Price was traded to Detroit.
  • Dearborn man bound for trial for fatal soccer referee punch

    Dearborn man bound for trial for fatal soccer referee punch

    Thursday, July 31 2014 7:14 PM EDT2014-07-31 23:14:05 GMT
    A Dearborn man will see a trial for second degree murder, accused of killing a soccer referee with one punch.Baseel Abdul-Amir Saad was bound over for trial in the death of John Bienewicz in 16th District Court today.Saad was ejected from an adult soccer game in Livonia -- when witnesses say he turned around and punched Bienewicz in the face June 29 .A Wayne County medical examiner testified that Bienewicz lost consciousness before he hit the ground.The defense said that it was a competitive ...
    A Dearborn man will see a trial for second degree murder, accused of killing a soccer referee with one punch.Baseel Abdul-Amir Saad was bound over for trial in the death of John Bienewicz in 16th District Court today.Saad was ejected from an adult soccer game in Livonia -- when witnesses say he turned around and punched Bienewicz in the face June 29 .A Wayne County medical examiner testified that Bienewicz lost consciousness before he hit the ground.The defense said that it was a competitive ...
  • Download the FOX 2 Apps


  • FOX 2 News Five-Day Forecast
Powered by WorldNow

KSAZ-TV & KUTP
511 W. Adams St.
Phoenix, AZ 85003

Phone: (602) 257-1234
Fax: (602) 262-0177

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices